Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts

Monday, January 30, 2012

The prophesy of envy

The essence of the neo-Conservative philosophy is rooted in a self-delusional hypocrisy -- that since all human beings are naturally fallen, sinful, and weak (a projection of their own psychology to others), then it is impossible for a secular human being to do good for others. And yet because the neo-conservative believes their own selves to be redeemed (exceptionally) by deity and therefore entitled to the individual blessings bestowed to me by the loving moral deity, they must protect their success and hoard their material blessings from those ostensibly lesser mortals who would only squander it. It is this way no matter how much suffering such lowly persons must endure, unless I, in my imagined righteousness, deign to stoop low so as to administer my condescending charity.

And therefore, because the basis of social justice and community is a collective loyalty and commitment to mutual liberty and equality, those who would rather distrust and exclude themselves from the global community on the basis of a conviction of their own unique exceptionalism, do thereby create a self-fulfilling prophesy which causes envy and classism defined by their very own selfishness, greed, and false righteousness.

Because after all, if others are actually only interested in their own personal well-being, but I assume that they are lying about their good-intentions (because after all, that is what I would do), then the only logical course is to pre-empt their exploitation of my trust by exploiting them first. This is the cold and calculating application of Merrill Flood's Prisoner's Dilemma game to not only world politics, but to people who's condemnable offense was not being born to a wealthy family in the Exceptional United States.

"As I watched the behavior of the nations of the U.N. (including our own), I found no reasonable ground to expect any one of those governments to transcend permanently their own national interests for those of another country."
-- Jeane Kirkpatrick, American ambassador and ardent anti-Communist

Conservatism: The assumption by psychological projection that others must think and behave as selfishly and as evilly as you do.

Monday, September 19, 2011

Imagine all the people...


So tonight on my way back from ACL, there were these insufferable street preachers yelling at people through megaphones telling them that we were all going to hell for listening to devil music and shit. They've been coming back there to the same spot for the past four years now.

Does anybody happen to know if Texas cities, or Austin specifically, require street demonstrators to acquire a license or anything of the sort?
Like ·  · 14 hours ago
  • Clint Mills and Beth Jurzec like this.
    • Luisa Lowry Oh geez.... :/ That is not the Gospel. Sorry you have to go through them.
      14 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson Oh they were quoting verses right out of Matthew. I recognized the words. Matthew is one of the Gospels alright.
      14 hours ago · Like
    • Carlos Ernesto Marin Well considering that fundamentalist Christians elected our governor and most of congress, even if there was a permit requirement, I doub't it would be enforced against them.
      14 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson There were actually uniformed officers (Austin PD) making sure that none of the crowds could get close to them. Plus they had legit 300 pound body guards. I am certain there had been violence before.
      14 hours ago · Like
    • Luisa Lowry Yes, Matthew is one of the books of the Gospels BUT their approach to Christianity is NOT the Gospel. Those people make me sad because that is not what true Christianity is about at all.
      14 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson ‎:-) Sorry, I love you Luisa, but I disagree. That's *exactly* what Christianity is all about. It's about trying to divide the world up into two different kinds of people -- the people who are going to heaven, and the people who are going to hell. That's all there is to it. Jesus said so himself.
      14 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson
      Luke 12:51 "Suppose you that I am come to give peace on earth? I tell you, No; but rather division: 52 "For from now on there shall be five in one house divided, three against two, and two against three. 53 "The father shall be divided against the son, and the son against the father; the mother against the daughter, and the daughter against the mother; the mother in law against her daughter in law, and the daughter in law against her mother in law." That's Jesus talking.
      14 hours ago · Like
    • Jon Burgin
      You misunderstand Nels, It is about all the people. All Jesus is saying is that one cannot compromise one's faith. One cannot say I'll only follow 9 of the 10 commandments so that I don't offend my neighbor. In this, there will be conflict,because one's believe will cause division. However, Jesus does not say to go condemning, which those men in Austin appear to be doing. It is unfortunate that so many focus on other's sins instead of their own. For me, I've got enough of my own mess to clean up to worry about what music someone is listening too.
      14 hours ago · Like ·  2 people
    • Anna Nelson That must be what they were shouting about on Saturday night too...glad we didn't stop to listen.
      7 hours ago · Like ·  1 person
    • Nels Nelson Good morning, Jon! :-) I don't think I misunderstand at all. Either the biblical passages are open for fuzzy interpretations to content oneself, or they mean what they clearly say. I have never once seen any precise and reasonable criteria by which metaphor could be distinguished from literalism in the bible.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson
      Also, I understand the bible very well. I also understand Christian communities very well. And while I admit that such communities are well-meaning, it is an unavoidable fact that the exact same creeds that are used to bond such communities are also often used to attack, humiliate, and abuse people outside of certain communities. This is the way of religious dogmas of all stripes, including the gospel creed, throughout history. That is simply inarguable. I am not picking on your creed of choice, Jon -- Christianity. I am saying that I understand Christianity very well, and I see absolutely zero difference between its substance, and any other religion in the world -- including ones adhered to by hate-filled individuals. Religion is an enabler of good, but also very, very immoral behavior.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson ‎Anna Nelson, last night, I stopped for a moment or two. I listened. They quoted scripture verses verbatim. From memory. Precisely. They were shouting them. With vitriol. They were passionate. They were true believers. Would everyone in the world be as passionate about what they believe -- the world would dine upon itself.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Jon Burgin
      If I hit you on the head with a candle stick. Is the candle stick evil? Is it designed for that purpose? Or am I the one doing wrong. I believe that the Luke 12:51 is merely stating that following Jesus is not without consequences. After all, none of the disciples died of old age. Nowhere there does it advocate conflict. Nor does it say that following Jesus is the cause of the conflict, nor does it say that others are the cause of the conflict. Any other interpretation is on your part.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Jon Burgin If you truly understand the bible well, I envy you. I don't think that it is easily understood. As far as the metaphor (or parable) and literalism, there actually is a method for distinguishing between the too. I am not a scholar on the topic, but I think it is pretty rigorous. If you are interested I can ask a more learned person and get the reference for you.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson I understand that is what you believe, Jon Burgin. I think that belief clouds your reasoning.

      I simply do not see how this can be interpreted in any other way: "Suppose you that I am come to give peace on earth? I tell you, No"

      Also, your namesake, John the Apostle, died of natural causes at the age of 94.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Jon Burgin Yup, I stand corrected. I don't dispute that he does not come to bring peace. But you said that Christianity advocates what those individuals in Austin were doing. You said that the Luke 12:51 says that you are suppose to go out and be hateful. It does not say that. It does not advocate an activity. It merely says that there will be conflict. What part of what I just said is 'clouded'?
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Jon Burgin
      I agree that we interpret differently. But I humbly suggest that it just might be not from difference in faith, but difference in understanding. By dismissing what I say with the clouded comment. You dismiss the possibility that you might be wrong. By claiming to understand well, you preclude the possibility of obtaining wisdom from the bible. The first step to wisdom starts with a question and and acknowledgement that there could be something we don't know.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson Now you are just misinterpreting *my* words, Jon. :-) That's what I mean by clouded.

      I never, ever, said that Luke 12:51 advocates hate-bringing and violence. What I said was that it clearly states that the world is divided up into two different groups of people -- people who are going to heaven from people who are going to hell.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Jon Burgin Louisa said "That is not the Gospel. Sorry you have to go through them." and you said that it was what Christianity is all about, meaning that there actions were gospel. Or am I misunderstanding something there?
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson Jon, that is exactly what they were doing. They weren't attacking anyone. Yeah, they had bodyguards. But they were just saying bible verses and telling everyone that they were going to hell unless they repented of their wicked ways.

      They were only doing what was commanded of them by their bible. The exact same bible in which you put your faith.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson
      Just because I state that I understand the bible, does not preclude wisdom harvesting from it. That makes no sense.

      When I was a young man, I had been a born again Christian for over a decade. My journey did indeed start with a question. That question was, among many, many others: why would the god of the bible, a supposedly infinitely loving being condemn billions perhaps trillions of souls to unimaginable suffering and torment for eternity in the afterlife?
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Jon Burgin In short he doesn't. But shoot, I got to work day job, lets talk sometime, I'd love to hear what you have to say on this.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson Oh, but he does indeed. Clearly you have not read the passages that state explicitly that he does. Either that, or you interpret them in a fuzzy way so that you can feel better about what you choose to believe.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson Not to mention the unimaginable suffering that is endured senselessly here in the real world. No loving interventionist god would allow such atrocities. It is illogical for a loving interventionist god to allow hundreds of thousands of innocent people to die in a tidal wave in the Indian Ocean in 2004. I could go on and on.
      3 hours ago · Like
    • Luisa Lowry Oh Nels... I'm still sorry that you had to go through them. And for all these questions and disagreements you have. Keep searching for the answers.
      2 hours ago · Like
    • Nels Nelson I'm not sorry in the least, Luisa. :-) I'm very sorry that you feel sorry for me. :-) That's such a shame.
      2 hours ago · Like




I think it is interesting that Jon uses the same argument (suggesting I might think a candlestick to be evil if he strikes me on the head with it) to defend religion that gun rights advocates use to defend their guns from wacko liberals who don't respect the Second Amendment -- that it is not the gun that kills, but the person holding the gun -- that it is not the religion that damns or goes on crusades, but the person adhering to the religion.

Similarly, the separation of the actor from the object, but with the opposite ascribed value: St. Augustine's famous phrase, "Cum dilectione hominum et odio vitiorum" or, "With love for mankind and hatred of sins."

Why not take the sentiment all the way? Love for the gun owners, hatred for the guns. Love for the murderers, hatred for murder. Love for the religious, hatred for the religion. Obviously there is something amiss about this line of thought. Surely concepts such as "sin" and religion cannot be qualified in the same terms as murder and guns?

And yet, a person does "sin". Just like a person does damning. Just like a person does shooting. Sin does not do the sinning for the sinner. Guns do not do the shooting for the shooter. However, religions, dogmas, creeds, they do the damning through the damner. Religions are just people, telling people, that people other than themselves are damned.

Sort of like corporations -- yeah, they're people -- but they're a bunch of people worshipping at the alter of a giant stack of money, and not just capable of committing but wont to commit horrible atrocities.

Religions are exactly the same. Yes, religion is just people. But they are a bunch of people worshipping at the alter of a deity or creed, and capable of even worse.

However, when people do good things, I am to believe that it is somehow the religion doing the good things, not just the person. The people are still the actors, but their faith in a higher power is what is enabling them to act in a moral manner. But the opposite? When the words of religious dogmas turn ugly? The damnation? We are to believe that those words originate with the people speaking them, not their faith in the one true god.

I'm sorry, but this is wrong. Religions and corporations alike are examples of group-think. Because they are by definition group identities, one cannot dissociate the individual from the group when it comes to their actions. The action of one member of the group is in fact the action of many, and conversely, the action of the group is in fact the collective action or tacitly approving inaction by the individual.

Just saying, "Oh I'm not in that group" or, "Well, no true Christian would ever... do such and such" is not enough. Quibbles and endless distinctions of dogmas and interpretations will be made, but the words are still there clear as day, binding religions and sects together whether all of their followers are comfortable with those words or not. The fact is that most followers of a religion will not even care enough to notice the contradictions in their sacred texts, let alone try to rationalize them, but will instead blindly follow what they are told by the group.

Individual people own nothing except for their actions and words. Bad actions are forgivable, sure. Good actions are commendable, of course. But religions are just the collections of words spoken a long time ago by a bunch of people who insisted upon themselves (and adopted by people who continue to insist upon themselves) and who were intolerant of your reason as well as your forgiveness.

You are capable of great wrong, not only despite your religion, but because of it. You are also capable of doing good, with or without it. Religion, however, is the enshrined belief of your ancestors that you are incapable of living without their guidance. Religion demands that you place your faith in their lack of faith in you to do what is right all on your own.

Thursday, September 09, 2010

Even a broken clock...

Until today there has been absolutely nothing that Glenn Beck has said that I did not wish I had never heard in the first place. His rhetoric is usually so inflammatory and stupid that it is impossible to escape it from either the reverent right or the lampooning left.

Surely you've heard about the plan hatched by Pastor Terry Jones of the Dove World Outreach Center church in Gainesville, Florida to hold a good old-fashioned down home book-burning of exclusively the Islamic holy book the Quran on September 11th.

Apparently so has Mr. Beck, and he weighed in with his opinion in this blog post.
What is wrong with us? It’s just like the Ground Zero mosque plan. Does this church have the right? Yes. Should they? No. And not because of the potential backlash or violence.
Update: Okay, no. The mosque is not being planned to be built on Ground Zero, for one thing. If it was, that might be a little weird. Calling it the "Ground Zero mosque" is just a straight up lie.

And besides, burning the Quran, and building a mosque two-blocks north of Ground Zero are not the same things at all.

But go on...
We must be the better person. We must be bigger than our problems. Bigger than the times in which we live. Burning the Koran is like burning the flag or the Bible. You can do it, but whose heart will you change by doing it? You will only harden the hearts of those who could be moved. None of those who are thinking about killing us will be affected, but our good Muslim friends and neighbors will be saddened. It makes the battle that they face inside their own communities even harder.
What?

This sounds measured and calm. It sounds well-reasoned. It actually sounds rather Christian in the idealistic turn-the-other-cheek sense of the word.

Well (almost) good for you Mr. Beck. You (almost) got one right this time.

Monday, April 27, 2009

Are you ready for the Rapture?

Did you know that the global climate is warming?

Well, today's Rapture index (166 and rising) is really high. So in terms of a spiritual global climate our planet is practically boiling!

The Rapture Index is a useful and extraordinarily accurate aggregation of all the factors that prophetically contribute to the likelihood that the Rapture will occur today (or pretty soon).

Hosted at RaptureReady.com, the Rapture Index is apparently put together by Todd Strandberg, the website's creator.

There are 45 categories used to calculate the Rapture Index. My favorite category that is considered to be directly contributing to the Rapture is probably "Liberalism". The site defines this category this way:
29. Liberalism
It's not just a part of the Democrat Party. liberalism is what could be called the "true conspiracy." Liberal media are 100 percent controlled by the forces that bow to humanistic ideology. [sic]
Liberalism is currently at a 4. I guess that's sort of like condition orange.

My analogy isn't very original though. Mollie Ziegler over at GetReligion.org used Department of Homeland Security's chart to illustrate her Rapture article way back in 2007.

Just in case you aren't paying attention to the index and you find that you have forgotten your Rapture Umbrella when it arrives, here's what to do:
If you're a wussy unbeliever, and you don't think you'll be able to control your bowel movements during the impending Rapture, you can stop worrying. The folks over at Tribulation Central have got you covered -- with Rapture Adult Diapers as well as other Rapture preparedness items.

Monday, February 02, 2009

The war on science

René Descartes: Cogito ergo sum.
Conservative Republican politicians and voters: Credo ergo est.

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

David Attenborough gets hate mail from Creationists

David Attenborough has apparently been receiving hate mail from Christian Creationists.

Christians everywhere should be ashamed. Christians who behave in this way are poison in the body of the Church.

Saturday, January 17, 2009

A second opinion on Dave Ramsey

In a recent blog post I wrote about how my company has been sponsoring Dave Ramsey personal finance classes.

In my experience, the value of the wisdom that Mr. Ramsey offers his customers is often questionable. This is not just my opinion, it is the opinion of many other people as well.

Of course, opinion of Ramsey is extremely varied. Many people seem to think that Ramsey is a the next best thing to a prophet sent by God. Others think rather the opposite of him. His approach to personal financial advice seems to have a polarizing effect on people. This apparently makes him a popular subject among bloggers.

Way back in April 2006 a fellow named Ariah Fine from Minneapolis wrote anecdotally about an episode of Ramsey's radio program. A woman called in and asked for some advice about a vehicle purchase decision over which she and her husband were deliberating.

Ariah Fine's opinion of Dave Ramsey is critical, but tamely so.

As Fine tells it, Ramsey's advice doesn't surprise me -- I've heard it before.

What does surprise me is the impressive number of comments on the post, especially considering the luke-warm tone of Fine's post. To date there have been 306 comments and still and counting three years later. The comments are widely varied, alternately digressive and tangential, and passionately written.

I had no idea that Ramsey was such a controversial figure, until I expressed my opinion of him -- that he is just another wanna-be messiah, a false prophet, and a snake-oil-salesman who sells nothing but common sense packaged with fluff, the tricks and illusions of slick marketing, and a convenient association with the Christian religion -- and was met with passionate opposition. Greg Lange notes many of the points often argued (and that I have argued) about Ramsey.

My first impression of Ramsey was that he seemed to have taken to the spotlight of motivational speaking like a true showman. He has the charisma of a new car salesman (American-made), and he consistently delivers smartly packaged morsels of enlightenment and crafted anecdotes like a professional preacher.

Ramsey is on AM talk radio every day. There he offers free financial advice to thousands who really need it. This would be commendable, and admirable, if he wasn't selling something at the same time. This air time is essentially a three hour commercial for himself and his products.

In fact, if I had to put my finger on one thing in particular that I dislike the most about Ramsey, it is his shameless self-promotion. Of course, for him this is necessary since his brand, Dave Ramsey, is all that differentiates his product from every other financial self-help product out there. The only thing Ramsey teaches is common sense principles about money management -- but because it is Dave teaching it, somehow that's worth three easy payments.

People are drawn to him. He has developed a large and ostensibly sustainable following over the years. The dramatic economic meltdown of 2008 only seems to guarantee a continued and prolonged success as new potential customers, desperate for hope and relief from financial burdens, are created every day.

Background

Certainly he deserves his prosperity. I honestly believe that. After all, he has found something in life that he is good at, and he does it for a living. We should all be so fortunate.

Of course, he certainly wasn't cut out for his first profession -- real estate.

Ramsey started out his real estate career in the foreclosure market around 1982. He would purchase houses below market value and then resell them for a profit. Leveraging that success, he got into the rental business, and soon he owned and operated $4 million worth of property. Towards the end of the 1980's however, his multi-million dollar real estate business went bust because he couldn't pay his creditors. He filed for bankruptcy after he was given a 90 day notice to pay $1.2 million worth of short-term notes.

Experiencing the financial failure of his business that he built with foreclosure and rent profits caused Ramsey to re-evaluate his approach to finances. Ramsey soon began to give one-on-one personal financial counseling to members of his church. That worked out well for him and so he began a limited liability incorporated company called Lampo Group to provide financial counseling services in 1991.

In 1992 he wrote a book about his failures and the lessons he learned since. Between 750,000 to a million copies have been sold as of 2008. At list price of $23.95, that is around $20 million dollars of revenue. Quite an accomplishment.

Since then he has written two more books (including one titled "How to Have More than Enough" and sold at Christian book stores everywhere) and is now the face of a large and rapidly growing media powerhouse that provides multiple services and resources for financial education. What was once a modest counseling business has been transformed into a phenomenon, and Dave Ramsey himself transformed into his company's brand.

Religion

Ramsey is a professed Christian, and some of the values of his religion do shine through in his talks and material. His main message of avoiding the burden of debt and living sensibly within one's means is an ideal of many Christians.

Yet at the same time, Ramsey's stated goal is to live, and teach his readers and audience to live, in a sensible way in order to accumulate wealth and "have more than you need". Certainly, he qualifies this goal with the recommendation of stewardship and charity, but the frequency of such statements are dwarfed by promises of earning a million dollars by retirement age. While this is not a lot of money, it is enough to put dollar signs, sports cars and hot tubs in the minds of his audience, who are often in dire financial straits. He enthusiastically promises wealth and luxury for those who follow his advice, and buy his book -- and people latch onto those promises and the hope that he offers.

As if he were following the example of another popular figure who found that being a born-again Christian has the advantages of an assumption of trustworthiness by a large support base of Evangelicals, Ramsey is more than just open about his religion, he emphasizes it. Although it is impossible to determine his genuineness, Ramsey shamelessly uses his Christian faith to promote his brand (himself). Because of this, a Christian perspective from his critics is more than suitable.

The Bible has much to say about money and the pursuit of wealth. Here are some references: Matthew 6:24, Matthew 19:21, Luke 18:22, Mark 10:21, 1 Timothy 6:10, Isaiah 55:2, Exodus 22:25.

Especially on the nose is this passage from Matthew chapter 6: verses 19 and 20.

Objections to my criticism of his exploitation and advertisement of his religion are predictable. However, there are passages in the Bible about teachers being required to stand up to a higher level of scrutiny. Here are those references: James 3:1, 2 Peter 2:1.

There are also passages that speak about the emptiness of words in the absence of love. Ramsey is a showman, first and foremost. It is simply inarguable that this characteristic is his single most important asset. It seems difficult to trust a showman because with such a person it is often impossible to distinguish what is sincere from what is facade. If Ramsey preaches love, charity, and sacrifice, it is a small bullet point on his PowerPoint presentation on money management. For motivation he emphasizes not virtue or a love for God and the less fortunate, but simple financial gain.

In other words, Ramsey is a money changer in the temple.

Ramsey seems to reject the opportunity that he has to address the real root causes of the downfall of individuals and families: greed, self-absorption, envy, and a market for labor made unfair by a United States currency that represents debt, and nothing more.

Supporters of Ramsey seem to dismiss the suffering of those experiencing financial difficulties as the result of poor decisions. In other words, their perspective is, poor people have made their bed, and now they must lay in it.

Ramsey does not advocate a holistic improvement of the sociological environment in this country. Ramsey is less concerned with making a real difference by educating, shepherding, and integrating disenfranchised citizens into the exclusive culture of prosperity in the United States than he is with promoting his brand and profiting from people's desperation. The Bible is clear about this kind of thinking and teaching: 1 Corinthians 13:1.

Politics

Ramsey has publicly aligned himself against Democratic politicians such as Barack Obama and Joe Biden. In a radio segment during the election race, Dave Ramsey rants redundantly for 7 minutes about politics, calling Joe Biden a "twit", an "idiot", and a communist. This clip will surely only further endear Ramsey to some.

Ramsey should keep his politics to himself, and to his credit, he mostly has. Economically speaking, I don't really find all that much on which I disagree with Ramsey. He supports a fair tax, and a fiscally responsible government, both of which are things that I think are good ideas. But he should still leave politics alone.

Already a divisive personality, the last thing Ramsey needs is to be perceived as a right-winger. Right-wing politics have allowed this country to be led right up towards the abyss, and its leader has not hesitated. There are still people out there who will argue with me on this one, so let me briefly elaborate.


Most economic and political analysts say that the fiscal policies of President Bush has been one of the single largest contributors in recent history to the national US debt. What's left of the defenders of Bush economic policy will claim that a liberal, Democratic Congress are somehow to blame for such insanities. This is impossible since the Republican party has been in control of Congress between 1995 and 2007.

As an example of fiscal responsibility, the Bush administration has been a failure. Americans have had a terrible role-model in their highest elected representative, and it shows. In the US, debt per family versus gross domestic product has risen dramatically and unprecedentedly since 2000 when Bush was elected.

When challenged to explain how the government was to continue to pay for an expensive war, Bush and proponents of the Bush tax cuts insisted they would "pay for themselves". It was apparently assumed that by putting more cash in taxpayer's pockets with which to purchase things, the demand for goods and services would increase, which in turn would increase trade and production. What Bush obviously doesn't understand is that Americans have been buying whatever they want, whenever they want, with higher taxes or lower, with or without any real money. Instead of money, Americans have been purchasing their "increased standard of living" with credit cards and cash loans against their mortgages. Currently the average household's credit card debt is $8,565.

Bush's tax cuts were indeed effective at stimulating the economy in the short term, and yet failed to prevent massive budget deficits. Lee Arnold explains using his remarkably simple ecolanguage developed precisely for complex economic subjects such as Bush's tax cuts. But I am digressing.

Bush appealed to the same ideological values to which Ramsey appeals, and yet Bush has consistently missed opportunities to demonstrate his supposed conservative values in the policies of his administration. For success, the Bush policies on the economy have relied on Americans continuing their selfish consumerism unfettered. It could only have lasted so long.

Ramsey ridicules Obama and Biden for their "Robin Hood" tax plans. Considering that Bush has been doing exactly the opposite by reducing capital gains taxes, benefiting richer Americans disproportionately, Obama's tax plan will more or less be simple compensation for the unbalance. Still, Ramsey seems to believe that McCain would have had a better tax policy. He can believe anything he wants, the American people have spoken.

Personally, I think that Ramsey is still a far better person than President Bush will ever be. But my contention remains: Ramsey should leave his politics out of his sales pitch. Again, like his religion, Ramsey is using his political views to attract a market demographic, and that is simply bad form. In fact, were it not for those things, I might be inclined to cut the man some slack.

Ramsey and bankruptcy

Shifting gears, I'd like to talk about Ramsey's stance on bankruptcy. He seems to believe that bankruptcy is perceived by many as an "easy way out". Bankruptcy is not easy in the least, he says, and should be avoided at all costs. He is right that bankruptcy is not easy, but to many his tremendously negative opinion of it as an option to people who have no other options just adds to the stigma and humiliation associated with the difficult decisioni to file and liquidate.

Ramsey reasons that he is a well-qualified expert on bankruptcy since he went through it himself. He is right to warn people that bankruptcy is not as easy as it might appear: "Few people who have been through bankruptcy would report that it is a painless wiping-clean of the slate, after which you merrily trot off into your future to start fresh." Who says that it is?

Chapter 7 bankruptcy involves being forced to sell off all non-exempt property in order to pay off your debts. Imagine losing your home, your car, a priceless family heirloom, the wife's jewelry, and so on. The emotional toll is inevitable. Many people who go through the bankruptcy process report battling with depression.

Bankruptcy is certainly not easy, but consider this: the median household income in the US is around $50,000. After taxes and the average monthly mortgage/rent payment ($684), that's about $2200 a month to split between 3 people per family. Seems difficult enough, but that's not even the average filer for bankruptcy, those are the numbers for average Americans. Most filers of Chapter 7 have lost a job and have suffered a significant decrease of their income. As mentioned earlier, the average household credit card debt in the US is around $9,000. In 2007, debtors filing for Chapter 7 reported median average monthly expenses of $2,433.

There are many different kinds of bankruptcy. Chapter 13 is a less commonly-selected option for individuals seeking debt-relief, but has some significant advantages over liquidation under Chapter 7. For one thing, Chapter 13 offers filers the opportunity to avoid a foreclosure on their home, in exchange for promising to pay off their debt over a longer period of time at a renegotiated, lower interest rate.

If the average bankruptcy filer took Dave Ramsey's advice and did all they could to avoid filing bankruptcy, their only alternative is years of paying off thousands, sometimes hundreds of thousands of dollars of debt at an interest rate entirely determined by their creditors. Who benefits the most from that? The credit card companies. People with credit card debt are slaves, plain and simple. What wouldn't you give to be free from slavery?

From a Christian perspective, the Bible is completely contradictory on this issue. Christian lawyers don't hesitate to use the Bible to ease the minds of potential clients on the matter. Yet, Christians who make their living offering personal financial advice use the Bible to oppose the taking of such action.

Also consider: roughly 2.0 to 2.5 million Americans seek the help of a credit counselor each year, mostly to avoid bankruptcy. This is Ramsey's market. If more people declare bankruptcy, that's less people from whom Ramsey can make money.

It seems far-fetched to suggest that Ramsey actually has an interest in keeping people in debt. Doesn't it? Considering the voracity with which credit card companies pursue people with poor money-management skills, perhaps not.

My opposition to the advice Ramsey offers on bankruptcy is mostly rhetorical, because bankruptcy is such a personal life decision. But really, Ramsey is the last person you should listen to for advice on the subject of bankruptcy.

If only...

Seriously though, if I could recommend anything for Dave Ramsey to do that would completely win me over, it would be this: stop selling your stuff.

Just don't put a price tag on it. Stop marketing it.

Instead, accept donations for your cause. Close the doors on Lampo Group Incorporated and start a foundation. Give yourself a modest salary, and disclose it.

Alternatives

First, as a counter example to Ramsey I draw your attention to Rick Warren. Warren is a Christian whose book The Purpose-Driven Life has brought him wild success and dramatic personal wealth. What he has done with the income from his publication is a humbling example to us all. I don't agree with everything Warren has to say, but he is still a good role-model.

Billy Graham is another example of personal integrity. In 1948 he and some associates penned "The Modesto Manifesto". The number one article in this manifesto was an insistence of a modest income so as to differentiate themselves from other televangelists of the day.

Next, please watch this anti-consumerism video by the Advent Conspiracy. It delivers a compelling message that transcends the now past Christmas season and is just as relevant to the new year. After all, as it is often asked, why can't we act like it's Christmas all year?

So, instead of buying crap you don't need, like Ramsey's books and online university memberships, just take my advice. It isn't even my advice, it's just common sense, so there's no charge:
  • Stop buying stuff with a credit card. Just stop using credit.
  • Pay off your credit cards or declare bankruptcy.
  • Can't keep up with the Joneses? Sell your house and move to a more modest neighborhood. Schools in the new neighborhood not good enough? Do something about it.
  • Have a budget. Have a plan. Add up how much you spend each month. Guesstimate if you have to. Extrapolate your yearly costs. If it turns out that you spend more than you make, figure something out. Reduce your spending.
  • Budget for saving.
  • Be disciplined and stick to your budget no matter what.
  • And finally, educate yourself. Learn. And don't listen to just one person. Read everything.
Here are some free personal financial advice websites:That's it.

Sound like too much sacrifice? Too much work? Not happy unless you're living the easy life? Maybe Ramsey does deserve your money, after all.